What You Will Learn and Why It Matters
New York’s local governments collected $23.0 billion in sales tax during 2023 and the trend keeps climbing. Auditors follow the money, so risk is rising for every seller with New York customers or inventory.
In the sections that follow, we will:
-
Break down the main state and local filing requirements
-
Explain how consultants reduce audit exposure and reclaim overpaid tax
-
Share the seven firms whose track records, credentials, and pricing impressed us most
-
Offer quick, do-it-today tips to stay compliant between professional check-ins
Let’s start with the rules you have to follow before you can judge who should help you follow them.
Understanding New York Sales Tax Obligations
New York State imposes a 4 percent base rate. Counties and many cities layer local rates on top, so the combined rate can reach 8.875 percent inside New York City. The mix gets more complicated when you add:
-
Destination-based sourcing for tangible goods
-
Special rules for clothing, prepared food, telecom services, and software subscriptions
-
Marketplace facilitator laws that shift collection duty to Amazon, Etsy, and similar platforms
Even businesses without a physical New York location can trigger economic nexus after $500 000 in sales and 100 separate transactions in the prior four quarters. For a comprehensive breakdown of how these nexus rules work for remote and multi-state sellers, see Economic Nexus.
Real-World Example: How a Small Rule Triggered Back Taxes
A Connecticut apparel brand selling on its own Shopify site crossed the threshold in September, received a nexus questionnaire in November, and discovered it owed three quarters of back tax because NYC’s clothing exemption only applies below $110 per item.
Keeping these details straight is a full-time job, which is why many companies hand it off to specialists. Unless you have internal tax staff that monitors every jurisdiction weekly, outside expertise is no longer optional, it is insurance.
Why You Might Need a Consultant
A seasoned consultant can save you far more than the invoice you pay.
They typically:
-
Register you for a Certificate of Authority, sometimes within 48 hours
-
Map product taxability so your ERP or shopping cart applies the correct rate
-
Build voluntary disclosure agreements (VDAs) that waive penalties on past-due tax
-
Defend you in audits, including preparing IDR responses and negotiating assessments
-
Recover overpayments lurking in poorly coded purchase invoices
For multi-state sellers, a global advisor such as 1stopVAT, which handles indirect tax in more than 100 countries, can centralize the process, sparing finance teams from juggling dozens of point solutions. To see exactly how a sales tax compliance partner supports registration, filing, and ongoing reporting, review Sales Tax Compliance: Key Steps for Your Business.
The bottom line: consultants reduce the two largest costs - penalties and internal time - while giving executives peace of mind.
How We Selected the Top Firms
Before naming names, here are the criteria we applied:
-
Licensing: New York CPAs, attorneys, or former Department of Taxation auditors
-
Industry focus: Proven success with ecommerce, SaaS, manufacturing, or retail
-
Pricing clarity: Published hourly rates or flat-fee menus, no “call for quote” black box
-
Service breadth: Registration, nexus studies, audit defense, and refund reviews
-
Client feedback: At least five recent verifiable testimonials or case studies
We also weighed geographic reach, technology support (without pushing automation software), and responsiveness during our secret-shopper calls.
With that framework, let’s meet the finalists.
The Top 7 New York Sales Tax Consulting Firms
Choosing the right fit depends on your transaction volume, internal resources, and growth plans. Use the profiles below as a starting point, then request proposals and references.
1. 1stopVAT
While best known for global VAT, 1stopVAT’s 40+ certified tax specialists streamline U.S. sales tax for exporters entering New York.
-
Services: NY registration, ongoing filings, cross-border tax reconciliation
-
Pricing: Bundled into their international compliance suite, starting at $4,000/year
-
Strength: One point of contact for U.S., EU, and APAC indirect taxes
-
Drawback: Geared toward companies already selling internationally
For an apparel brand shipping from Brooklyn to Berlin, having a single adviser cover both New York sales tax and German VAT removed a big expansion hurdle.
Choosing from these seven depends on scope, risk tolerance, and budget. Request engagement letters that spell out deliverables and timelines before signing. For additional suggestions and evaluation criteria, check the independent breakdown at Top Sales Tax Compliance Firms for Businesses.
2. Clinton & Harper CPAs
A mid-size CPA firm with a dedicated SALT division and offices in Albany and Buffalo.
-
Services: Multistate compliance, VDA negotiations, sales tax on construction projects
-
Pricing: $3 500 annual compliance package for sellers under $1 million in NY revenue
-
Strength: Integrated income-tax planning, helpful for pass-through entities
-
Drawback: Audit representation billed separately at $300/hour
Their work with a SaaS startup clarified that certain modules qualified as nontaxable custom software, slashing monthly collections by 8.875% in NYC accounts.
3. Hudson Indirect Tax Services
A boutique consultancy that partners with midsize ecommerce brands.
-
Services: Product taxability mapping, marketplace facilitator compliance, notice resolution
-
Pricing: $150 per SKU mapping, $900 per quarterly filing package
-
Strength: Deep Shopify and BigCommerce integrations
-
Drawback: Not ideal for manufacturers with exemption-certificate needs
Clients praise their online dashboard that flags rate changes in real time.
4. Empire State Tax Counsel
Led by two former Assistant Attorneys General, this law firm handles high-stakes controversies.
-
Services: Litigation, appeals, negotiated settlements, tax strategy opinions
-
Pricing: Retainer starts at $10 000, contingency fees for refund cases
-
Strength: Ability to take cases to the Division of Tax Appeals if negotiations stall
-
Drawback: Overkill for routine filings
A C-store chain recovered $1.3 million in overpaid prepaid gas tax after Empire State proved misclassification.
5. River & Fifth Advisory
A New York City consultancy specializing in hospitality and food-service operators.
-
Services: Sales tax compliance, cash vs. accrual planning, tip allocation guidance
-
Pricing: $600 setup, $250 per monthly return across all five NYC boroughs
-
Strength: Bilingual English-Spanish staff who train front-of-house teams
-
Drawback: Niche focus means limited experience with digital goods
Restaurants facing surge pricing and delivery-app complexities often find their guidance indispensable.
6. Metro Nexus Analytics
Data-driven firm using proprietary rate-scraping tools to monitor 3 000+ localities.
-
Services: Threshold alerts, economic-nexus dashboards, exemption-certificate tracking
-
Pricing: SaaS dashboard $99/month, consulting $200/hour
-
Strength: Real-time alerts minimize accidental nexus triggers in new counties
-
Drawback: Requires internal staff to act on dashboard insights
Although Metro offers a software element, their consulting team does the hands-on work, so you get human judgment, not just code.
7. NYSTax Advisory Group
Founded by former NYS Department of Taxation auditors, this Manhattan-based firm focuses solely on state and local tax.
-
Services: Nexus studies, registrations, audit defense, refund reviews
-
Pricing: Flat $2,000 for registration plus first return, $250/hour thereafter
-
Strength: Insider knowledge of auditor playbooks often shortens exams
-
Drawback: Limited capacity, so onboarding can take four weeks during peak periods
A Long Island distributor we spoke with trimmed its proposed assessment by 67% after NYSTax disputed the auditor’s sourcing methodology.
What Do New York Sales Tax Consultants Do?
New York sales tax consultants handle nexus evaluation, registration, product taxability mapping, return filing, audit defense, and refund recovery. The best firms combine licensed CPAs or attorneys, transparent pricing, and proven results in New York’s layered state, county, and city tax system.
Practical Tips to Stay Compliant Between Consultant Check-Ins
Hiring a specialist does not absolve you of day-to-day responsibility. Keep these habits to reduce surprises:
-
Reconcile sales data to filed returns monthly, not quarterly
-
Archive exemption certificates digitally and check expiration dates every six months
-
Monitor local rate changes, especially if you sell into counties where 50 of 57 saw collections rise in 2023
-
Watch economic-nexus thresholds: New York City’s tax receipts grew 5.9% in 2023 and auditors target fast-growing online sellers
-
Document taxability decisions with citations to NY Tax Law Sections and TSB-M memos
If you discover prior exposure or missed filings, a voluntary disclosure agreement may help limit penalties; see the step-by-step Global – Guide to Voluntary Disclosure Agreements for a practical overview. These simple checkpoints keep your consultant’s workload lower and your invoices smaller.
Conclusion
New York’s complex patchwork of state and local sales taxes can feel overwhelming, but the right consultant converts that uncertainty into a routine process. Whether you want a boutique firm that knows every auditor by name or a global adviser who can also handle cross-border obligations, the seven consultants above cover all budgets and scenarios. Combine their expertise with vigilant internal bookkeeping, and you will stay on the right side of a tax system that collected $23.4 billion in 2024 and shows no sign of slowing.
