Imagine getting hit with a penalty of an amount equal to 20% of the overstated VAT reimbursement. All because of a simple mistake on your tax return, with no intent to cheat the tax office and no money lost by the state. Yet, for many businesses across the EU, this is a real risk. One small error in reporting your VAT refund could lead to a huge financial hit.
VAT rules are strict. Many companies worry about making honest mistakes and ending up with unfair penalties. In fact, in the landmark Case C‑935/19, a Polish business faced such a penalty. They overstated their VAT refund completely by accident, fixed the error when they spotted it, yet still got slapped with a 20% penalty. This case isn’t just about one company. It affects everyone dealing with VAT in the EU. It shows how easy it is for anyone to land in trouble and why clear, fair tax laws matter for everyone.
Here’s the good news. The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that these automatic and harsh penalties do not match EU law, especially if there is no fraud or tax loss involved (CJEU Judgment in Case C‑935/19). In this article, you’ll learn what the court decided, what it means for your business, how intent and proportionality now play a bigger role in VAT penalty cases, and simple ways to protect your business from similar risks. Let’s make sure a small filing error never turns into a major headache.
Start with Strong VAT Compliance for Peace of Mind
Getting VAT compliance right means more than just following rules, it’s about keeping your business safe from penalties and stress. VAT compliance is all about making sure every number you put on your tax return is correct and matches actual business activity. Accurate reporting protects your company from unnecessary risks and reputation damage. In our experience, most VAT mistakes come from everyday errors like using the wrong VAT rate, forgetting to attach a supporting invoice, or misunderstanding which transactions are taxable. While these feel minor, they matter. Most EU countries monitor these details closely, often through surprise audits or automated system checks. This means one slip can trigger a review, and if you’ve overstated a VAT refund, the penalty can be swift.
Common VAT errors include:
- Misclassifying exempt vs taxable transactions.
- Relying on out-of-date VAT rules.
- Simple human typing or calculation mistakes.
Tip: Train your finance team regularly and use up-to-date software for every VAT calculation. This single step can cut your audit risk in half.
For more insights on real-world VAT penalties and their impact on businesses, see our recent case study: VAT Compliance: How EU Businesses Lost €159M in Penalties.
What Really Happened in Case C‑935/19? The €200,000 Lesson
Let’s break down the famous court case. A Polish company, Grupa Warzywna, bought a property and wrongly believed they should get a VAT refund for the deal. Simply put, they called an exempt transaction taxable, so they claimed a refund the state didn’t owe them. It was a genuine mistake, and they fixed it as soon as tax authorities pointed it out.
But here’s the shocker: the tax office demanded a penalty of an amount equal to 20% of the overstated VAT reimbursement anyway, even though there was no sign of fraud or tax loss. This opened the door to big questions about fairness and how the law treats honest mistakes. Suddenly, every business in Europe had reason to worry their own small mistake could land them with a huge bill. You can read the actual judgment here: CJEU Judgment in Case C‑935/19.
The CJEU Weighs In: Penalties Must Fit the Mistake
The European Court of Justice (CJEU) stepped in and said penalties like this can’t be automatic. Instead, tax authorities must check whether there was fraud or real harm to the state. The CJEU made it clear: honest mistakes should not be treated as if someone tried to cheat. Basically, if you made a genuine error with no tax revenue lost, automatic penalties like 20% of the overstatement go against the spirit of the VAT Directive 2006/112/EC and the EU principles of fairness and proportionality.
What’s important here is that Article 273 allows countries to set their own penalties, but only if they are fair and take the actual situation into account (VATUpdate: ECJ C‑935/19 Grupa Warzywna).
Why This Change Matters for Every VAT-Registered Business
For every business in the EU, this ruling is a game changer. The judgment means honest mistakes in your VAT return can no longer trigger a penalty of an amount equal to 20% of the overstated VAT reimbursement, as long as there’s no evidence of deliberate fraud or loss to the tax office. That’s real protection for companies who act in good faith.
We recently helped a client who feared a major penalty after discovering they had incorrectly reported input VAT for several months. The new ruling meant we could show it was a simple bookkeeping error with no tax loss, and the tax authority waived the harsh penalty. You’re not alone if you worry about these situations – this new standard applies to all tax offices in the EU now.
How to Bulletproof Your VAT Process Against Innocent Mistakes
Staying safe from VAT trouble is easier than you think, but it does take some careful planning. Start by putting extra checks in your processes:
- Double-check all tax return entries, especially for high-value transactions.
- Document every refund claim with supporting receipts and explanations.
- Use accounting software that highlights common VAT errors.
Act fast if you spot a mistake. Fixing it quickly and telling the tax office helps show there was no intent to cheat. The new legal standard now gives you a real shield if you do the right thing.
If you regularly handle VAT refund claims, you may also want to review our practical guide: EU VAT Refund: Practical Guidelines.
Internal Controls: Your Best Friend for VAT Safety
Building strong internal controls will keep your VAT filings clean. We suggest companies build a simple table to track checks and signoffs:
| Task | Who Reviews It | How Often | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reconcile invoices | Accountant | Monthly | Double-check VAT rates |
| Review refunds | CFO | Quarterly | Look for unusual patterns |
| Staff training | HR | Annually | Use recent VAT case studies |
This isn’t just paperwork. These checks catch the small things before they grow into major problems.
Get Expert Help When You Need It
Sometimes, the rules aren’t clear. When in doubt, contact VAT specialists (like our team at 1stopVAT.com) or use reliable resources to check your understanding. Professional help is an investment that pays for itself if it prevents even one big penalty. Also, keep an eye on updates in EU and local VAT law, since rules change and what was right last year could trip you up today.
The bottom line? The judgment in Case C‑935/19 marks a big step toward fairer tax treatment for ordinary businesses. Mistakes happen. But now, penalties must be fair, and you have clear ways to protect your business from nasty surprises.
Common Questions Companies Ask
If you spot an error in your VAT return, act quickly. Correct the mistake and inform your local tax office as soon as possible. This shows you did not intend to hide anything. Prompt action helps lower the risk of penalties, especially after the CJEU’s ruling on fairness.
If your mistake was genuine and did not cause any loss to the tax office, you should not face an automatic 20% penalty. The latest EU law, thanks to Case C‑935/19, says the penalty must match the seriousness of the mistake. Honest errors should be looked at differently than deliberate fraud.
Create good habits now. Double-check all VAT entries, keep clear records, train your staff, and use up-to-date software. A simple checklist for monthly and quarterly reviews can help you catch errors before you submit your return.
If the VAT rules seem unclear or your business faces a big transaction, reach out to a VAT expert. It is better to ask for advice early instead of fixing costly mistakes later. VAT specialists stay updated on law changes and know how to handle tricky cases.
Good faith means you tried your best to follow the rules and had no plan to cheat or hide information. Keeping records, fixing errors quickly, and talking to tax authorities if you find a mistake all show you are acting honestly and responsibly.
Final thoughts
Honest mistakes happen, and now, EU law protects business owners from unfair penalties like the 20% rule for VAT overstatements. The best way to stay safe is to build strong habits: double-check your returns, keep careful records, and ask for expert help when unsure.
These steps save you stress and money, helping your business avoid nasty surprises. 1stopVAT is here when you need the right advice.
Register for a FREE consultation
We offer a FREE consultation to better understand your needs. This could result in a simple solution to your taxes issues or lead to a more collaborative working relationship. Let’s find out what’s the best solution for you!
Book a Free consultation (worth 500 EUR)
What are the consequences of not being compliant?
How to ensure compliance?