The European Court of Justice(ECJ) and the EU General Court have had more than a few cases before them to decide on the rights of taxable persons to claim input tax credits, where different administrative/compliance VAT conditions haven’t been met within the formally mandated time frameworks established by national legislation.
One of the core VAT principles is neutrality, which could be practically translated as: when the business makes taxable supplies, that taxable person or the taxable person that makes that purchase, only to later supply it to the final consumer, should be able to recover input tax credit, as the VAT is the tax that is ultimately paid by the consumer.
However, there are many situations where the business fails to register for VAT on time. What happens then? Can late VAT registration impede a business from reclaiming its input tax credit?
The ECJ ruling in Rotex Europe Ltd (T-84/26) clarifies that the VAT neutrality principle and the right to reclaim VAT prevail over formal/administrative VAT registration requirements in Member States.
Case Background
Rotex Europe Ltd (company), established in the UK, purchased agricultural and food-processing machinery from suppliers in Bulgaria and subsequently sold the goods to customers in other EU Member States.
The company registered late for VAT in Bulgaria, and only after the registration, the company declared both its pre-registration purchases and sales and claimed a deduction for the input VAT incurred on those purchases, reclaiming an input VAT refund of app. EUR 900 000.
Bulgarian tax authorities refused the refund application because, under domestic VAT rules, to be able to claim input tax credits, the non-registered person(only registered later) needs to have the goods previously purchased. The company sold its products earlier, so the condition couldn’t be met.
The Supreme Administrative Court of Bulgaria made a request for a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU before the EU General Court, which later transmitted the case to the ECJ.
ECJ Request
The key question before the ECJ was whether the EU VAT law permits a Member State to make the VAT deduction of pre-registration VAT conditional, based on the necessity of physical presence of the goods previously acquired on the date when the VAT registration becomes official.
The Court stated that the right to deduct VAT is a major element of the EU’s VAT system, and it shouldn’t be abandoned where the material conditions for deduction are met.
ECJ Decision in Rotex Europe Ltd
The Court reaffirmed that the foundations of the Common EU Law block unilateral decisions by Member States tax authorities to automatically deny a VAT deduction right on the goods purchased before the VAT registration merely because those goods aren’t physically present on the registration date.
A taxable person who can materially prove that the goods were purchased and used for taxable business activities cannot lose its fundamental right only because a formal/administrative condition wasn’t met.
The Court explained that this sort of condition is incompatible with EU VAT law and the principles of fiscal neutrality and proportionality.